Dinner ideas

Dinner ideas for picky eaters: one dinner everyone can eat

With a picky eater at the table, the setup usually matters more than the recipe. Serve the parts separately, keep one portion plain, and let each person build their own plate.

Tell us who is eating and what the picky rules are, and the quiz suggests three dinners that fit your table tonight. The table tips are below.

Start the quiz with your picky rule already picked:

Nothing green Sauce on the side Foods can't touch Plain please

Download on the App Store

Seven days to see if it fits your week. If it doesn't, cancel before the trial ends and you pay nothing. A$9.99 a month in Australia, US$9.99 in the US, C$9.99 in Canada or NZ$9.99 in New Zealand, or 89.99 a year in the same currency.

Last checked: 12 October 2026

How to set up one dinner for a picky eater

Serve the parts, not the dish. Put the pasta, the sauce and the cheese in separate bowls. Each person builds their own, and nobody has to pick anything out.
Take a plain portion out before you season. Before the spice, sauce or chilli (chili) goes in, set aside some plain chicken, mince (ground beef), rice or pasta. It cooks in the same pan.
Put one food on every plate that they already eat. Rice, bread, cheese, plain pasta: whatever is a yes for that person goes next to whatever is new.
Keep new foods small and on the side. A spoonful in its own corner of the plate, with nobody watching to see if it gets eaten.
Change the shape, not the dinner. Strips instead of a whole schnitzel, a wrap cut in half, a bowl instead of a plate. Same food, easier to start on.
Keep allergy rules apart from picky rules. A dislike is a preference. An allergy is not. Cook the allergy-safe portion first with clean tools, and read every label.

Six dinners that already work this way

These come from the dinners in the quiz. Each has a table tip for keeping one plate plain while everyone else adds what they like.

Taco night, everyone builds their own. Keep a little mince aside before the spice goes in. A plain mince and cheese taco is still taco night. Allergens: gluten, milk.
Spaghetti bolognese, sauce on the side. Toss one bowl of pasta in butter and parmesan before any sauce goes near it. Whoever's unsure can add a spoon of sauce from there. Allergens: gluten, milk.
Egg fried rice with whatever's in the freezer. The plain bowl has rice, egg, corn and carrot, and nothing green. Soy sauce goes on the table for anyone who wants it. Allergens: egg, soy, gluten.
Burger night. A patty and cheese in a bun, cut in half, is a burger. The rest of the bar is for whoever wants it. Allergens: gluten, milk.
Flatbread pizzas. Write initials on the baking paper so each pizza goes back to its owner. Allergens: gluten, milk.
Jacket (baked) potatoes with a topping bar. Butter and cheese first, beans last. Each person stops when they want. Allergens: milk, gluten.

See all of them, matched to your table, in the 30-second quiz.

Check your labels

The allergens above are the ones in the usual version of each dish. Brands differ, and so do spice mixes, sauces, sausages, wraps and stock. The nine to look for are milk, egg, gluten, nuts, peanuts, fish, shellfish, soy and sesame. Read the label on every packet, every time.

When to talk to someone

Talk to your doctor or a children's dietitian if you are worried, for example about gagging, weight loss, or a very short list of foods your child will accept. This page is about setting up dinner, not about feeding problems.

How PULS3 helps

PULS3 is a team of coaches in an iPhone app that plans training, food and sleep together. Dinner is one part of it. Three things help when one table has different rules:

The week's dinners are planned for everyone at the table. Each dinner is checked against everyone's allergies. That is a second check, not a replacement for reading the label.
Photograph your fridge or pantry. You confirm what PULS3 found, and your dinner plans use it.
Tell PULS3 what each person won't eat. The week's dinners are planned around it: a dinner someone doesn't like comes with a version that leaves it out, or the night is re-planned.

PULS3 is coaching, not medical care. It does not diagnose or treat allergies or feeding problems, and it is not a replacement for advice from your doctor. For the rest of the team, see PULS3 for you. For more dinner ideas, see all dinner ideas.

Download on the App Store

Questions

What do you make for dinner when someone is a picky eater?

Usually the same dinner as everyone else, set up differently. Serve the parts in separate bowls, take a plain portion out before the sauce or spice goes in, and let each person build their own plate. Tacos, burgers, jacket potatoes and pasta with the sauce on the side all work this way.

How do I meal plan for a picky eater?

Plan dinners that can be served in parts, so the picky eater's plate and everyone else's come from the same cooking. Keep one food on each plate that the picky eater already eats. PULS3 plans the week's dinners for everyone at your table and checks each one against everyone's allergies, if you would rather not plan it yourself.

What are some easy dinners for picky eaters?

Taco night, burger night, flatbread pizzas, jacket potatoes with a topping bar, egg fried rice with a plain bowl taken out before the soy sauce, and spaghetti bolognese with the sauce on the side. Each one lets a picky eater keep it plain while everyone else adds what they like. Check the allergens on each before you cook.

What if my child only eats a few foods?

PULS3 provides coaching guidance, not medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Allergen notes on this page are general and are not a guarantee. Always read the label.